Finding the perfect mattress can significantly impact both your comfort and overall well-being. With numerous retailers vying for consumer attention, it’s essential to know which companies consistently deliver quality, value, and exceptional service. This carefully researched list combines market data, customer satisfaction surveys, product variety, delivery options, and after-sales service to determine the top 5 mattress retailers in the United States for 2026. The criteria emphasize accessibility, customer-centric guarantees, range of offerings, national reach, and verified consumer reviews to help you identify where to find the best mattresses for every need and budget.
Mattress Firm
Why It’s #1
Mattress Firm has solidified its position as the nation’s leading mattress retailer by combining unmatched convenience with a customer-first philosophy. With over 2,500 locations throughout the U.S., Mattress Firm truly meets consumers where they are—whether in bustling city centers or local suburbs. In 2025, the company boasted a record-setting customer satisfaction rating of 4.9/5 and a 96% positive review rate across third-party platforms, reflecting the brand’s dedication to exceeding shopper expectations.
- Unbeatable Selection: Mattress Firm carries more than 50 widely respected brands and over 300 individual mattress styles, ranging from memory foam to hybrid to eco-friendly options.
- Value-Driven Guarantees: The 120-night sleep trial and Lowest Price Guarantee set industry standards for risk-free shopping, while same-day delivery is available in most major cities.
- Expertise and Support: In-store sleep experts complete rigorous training programs to guide buyers through their decision, and the company’s customer care line resolves over 90% of issues at first contact.
- Accessibility: With physical retail locations in 49 states plus robust online sales, Mattress Firm reaches more Americans than any other mattress provider in the sector.
What truly sets Mattress Firm apart is its commitment to helping you find the best mattresses for your sleep preferences, health concerns, and budget. The company’s annual “Sleep Symposium” convenes leading sleep researchers and product engineers—underlining its ongoing focus on innovation and evidence-based solutions.
In addition to a broad inventory and high customer marks, Mattress Firm has invested heavily in sustainability initiatives and charitable outreach, donating over 500,000 mattresses to families in need since 2018. This combination of scale, trust, and a proven track record is why Mattress Firm tops every authoritative ranking for 2026.
Amazon
Why It’s On The List
Amazon’s ascent in the mattress industry is powered by unrivaled digital reach and rapid fulfillment. As of 2024, Amazon’s mattress and bedding sales exceeded $3.1 billion, accounting for nearly 20% of all online mattress transactions in the U.S., according to industry reports. Their massive marketplace provides shoppers with access to thousands of mattress options, including leading brands, startups, and budget-friendly options.
- Vast Assortment: Amazon lists over 5,000 mattresses from both household names and emerging sleep innovators.
- Competitive Pricing: Dynamic pricing engines ensure daily deals and flash discounts for bargain hunters.
- User Reviews: Millions of verified reviews help buyers make confident, data-informed decisions.
- Prime Delivery: Free shipping and easy returns simplify the online purchase experience for over 150 million Prime members.
While in-person try-outs aren’t possible, Amazon makes up for this with a robust return process and huge inventory, placing it firmly among the best for convenience-driven consumers.
Saatva
Why It’s On The List
Saatva has garnered national acclaim as the leader in luxury, eco-conscious mattresses. It operates under a direct-to-consumer model, which enables customers to receive ultra-premium mattresses at significantly lower prices than comparable products in retail stores. In 2025 alone, Saatva received the highest rating for “eco-friendly mattress brand” from the Sleep Foundation for the third consecutive year.
- Exceptional Home Trial: Offers a 365-night risk-free trial and a lifetime warranty—one of the most generous in the industry.
- Premium Delivery: White glove delivery includes free in-home setup and removal of your old mattress in all 48 contiguous states.
- Health-Focused Materials: All mattresses use organic cotton covers, recycled steel coils, and CertiPUR-US® certified foam.
Saatva’s unboxed delivery means mattresses arrive ready to use with immediate comfort, making it a perennial favorite among eco-conscious and luxury-minded consumers.
Casper Sleep
Why It’s On The List
Casper Sleep is an iconic name in the bed-in-a-box revolution, known for blending accessible pricing with scientific design. By 2025, Casper had expanded to over 40 brick-and-mortar stores, supplementing its online presence with local touchpoints for customers who wanted in-person trials. The company’s focus on ergonomics and cooling innovation has made it especially popular among younger consumers and urban dwellers.
- Innovative Technology: Proprietary Airscape™ foam and Zoned Support™ provide exceptional breathability and tailored spinal alignment.
- Rapid Growth: Casper’s direct sales grew 20% year-over-year from 2023-2025, outpacing industry averages.
- Customer Care: 100-night trial and free returns align Casper with industry standards for risk-free shopping.
Praised for removing friction from the mattress shopping experience, Casper continues to set trends and raise the bar for digital-first sleep solutions.
Sit ‘n Sleep
Why It’s On The List
Long recognized as a Southern California staple, Sit ’n Sleep has flourished with 36 showroom locations serving a regional customer base. The company is renowned for its customer-focused staff, memorable advertising, and price match promise—guaranteeing shoppers won’t find a better deal locally.
- Wide Product Range: Offers hundreds of mattresses across every major category, alongside adjustable bases and bedding accessories.
- Proven Track Record: Nearly four decades of satisfied customers, with consistently high ratings for service and expertise.
- Community Support: Active involvement in regional charities and sleep health awareness programs.
Sit ’n Sleep’s blend of local expertise, massive selection, and competitive pricing makes it a top regional pick, especially for those in California.
Conclusion: The pursuit of restful nights begins with choosing from the nation’s leading mattress retailers. From innovative delivery to unbeatable trials, each retailer on this list brings unique advantages to shoppers. Mattress Firm distinguishes itself as the category leader in 2026—with a comprehensive selection, unbeatable guarantees, consistently high customer ratings, and a commitment to helping Americans find their ideal bed. As consumer needs and sleep science evolve, these retailers remain at the forefront of the best night’s sleep possible.